Commodity price breadth
Are commodity price gains broad-based across sectors, or concentrated in energy and a few metals?
Edited by Finquill Research · Updated Oct 27, 2026
Review cadence: Weekly review; re-checked on each monthly World Bank Pink Sheet, the World Bank's Commodity Markets Outlook and Cochilco's quarterly copper forecast. Not daily.
Reviewed by the editor · Analytics, not advice
Free account. See what changed since your last visit, and the dates to watch on your calendar. Following never means agreeing.
Short answer (data to 21 October 2026). Concentrated, with a spillover. Since the first quarter of 2026 the largest gains were in energy (+41%) and grains (+21%) on the World Bank's monthly price indices. Base metals added 9% and precious metals fell 14%. In September alone the energy index rose 25.7% while the non-energy index rose 1.3%. Against 2025 averages the picture looks broader, because metals had already risen before the energy shock. The answer therefore depends on the base period, and this narrative states the base every time.
What changed in this update
The first update, published Oct 27, 2026.
What's next
Dated tests · set down in advance, graded by the editor
Due Nov 3, 2026 · awaiting the editor's grade · CPER
The World Bank Pink Sheet of 3 November 2026 shows October's base metals index at or above September's 166.2. Recorded as a pre-registered test, not a forecast.
Due Nov 3, 2026 · awaiting the editor's grade · DBC
The World Bank Pink Sheet of 3 November 2026 shows October's energy index below September's 148.9 while the non-energy index stays at or above 130.5. Recorded as a pre-registered test, not a forecast.
Jan 15, 2027 · DBC
The World Bank Pink Sheet published in early January 2027 shows the Q4 2026 non-energy index average at or above Q3 2026's 128.4. Recorded as a pre-registered test, not a forecast.
Open questions
- World Bank Commodity Markets Outlook (listed for October 2026, date not posted): does it project energy falling in 2027 while metals hold, and how does it revise April's 16% rise for 2026?
- Copper stocks (Cochilco daily reports): does the COMEX stockpile of 718,381 tonnes start flowing back to the LME and Shanghai, and does LME cash hold above $14,000 a tonne?
- Cochilco's next quarterly copper forecast: is the 2026 refined surplus of 225,000 tonnes revised, and does the $5.95 a pound 2026 average forecast move toward the year-to-date $6.12?
- The legs: EIA's Short-Term Energy Outlook on 10 November (Hormuz oil shock narrative) and WGC's Q3 Gold Demand Trends in early November (Gold after the fall).
Already happened
These dates have passed; the questions are kept as they were asked.
- Nov 3, 2026 · World Bank Pink Sheet (3 November, October averages): does the energy index ease while non-energy and base metals hold, or does everything move together?
The analysis
The breadth gauge (World Bank Pink Sheet, indices 2010=100, published 2 October).
| Index | Sep 2026 | vs 2025 average | vs Q1 2026 average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy | 148.9 | +65% | +41% |
| Non-energy | 130.5 | +13% | +8% |
| Agriculture | 121.3 | +5% | +9% |
| Grains | 125.4 | +24% | +21% |
| Fertilizers | 147.0 | +6% | −5% |
| Base metals | 166.2 | +36% | +9% |
| Precious metals | 338.6 | +31% | −14% |
The percentage changes are Finquill's arithmetic on the published indices. Within metals the split is sharp: copper averaged $14,474 a tonne in September, 45.5% above its 2025 average, while iron ore's September average was 2.5% below 2025's (both World Bank).
Copper, the metal this narrative follows directly.
- London Metal Exchange (LME) cash copper was $14,441 a tonne on 21 October. Its average for the year to date, $13,516, is 40.3% above the same point in 2025 (Cochilco, Chile's state copper commission).
- Exchange stocks are concentrated in the United States: 718,381 tonnes on COMEX (20 October), against 245,275 on the LME (21 October) and 73,962 on the Shanghai Futures Exchange (16 October).
- Cochilco's August forecast has a refined surplus of 225,000 tonnes in 2026, 0.8% of world demand, and 179,000 tonnes in 2027. It says the surplus does not mean oversupply, because inventories concentrated in the US restrict availability in Asia.
- Cochilco names the supply constraints: the slow recovery of Grasberg (Indonesia), difficulties at Kamoa-Kakula (DR Congo) and lower output at Codelco, Escondida and Spence.
- In August Cochilco forecast average prices of $5.95 a pound for 2026 and $5.10 for 2027. Copper closed at $6.6 a pound on 16 October; Cochilco attributed that week's dip to the labour agreement at Escondida, US inflation pressure and investor selling.
The legs this narrative links to. Energy is the largest contributor; the Hormuz oil shock narrative covers it, including EIA's forecast that Brent averages $84 in 2027 against an expected $96 in 2026. Precious metals are covered in Gold after the fall.
What would settle it. Broadening would show as the non-energy and base-metals indices still rising after energy eases. Concentration would be confirmed if energy falls and the rest stalls. The tests: the World Bank's next Pink Sheet (3 November), its Commodity Markets Outlook (listed for October, date not posted), Cochilco's next quarterly copper forecast, the energy and gold legs' November tests.
Strongest alternative
Broader than it looks. Read against 2025 averages, the rise is wide: base metals are 36% higher, metals and minerals 31%, precious metals 31% and grains 24% (Finquill's arithmetic on the World Bank's September indices). Copper's year-to-date average is 40% above the same point in 2025 on Cochilco's data. In April the World Bank expected overall commodity prices to rise 16% in 2026, with record highs for several key metals. On this reading, metals are rising on their own supply constraints (Grasberg, Kamoa-Kakula and Chilean output, per Cochilco), not on energy, and breadth would persist even if Gulf oil flows recover as EIA assumes.
What would count against it: the non-energy index stalling or falling once energy eases; COMEX copper stocks flowing back to London and Shanghai and pulling copper toward Cochilco's lower forecast averages; or grains and fertilizers easing with fuel costs, which would mark them as energy pass-through rather than independent demand.
Developments
Oct 21, 2026
COMEX holds 718,381 tonnes of copper against 245,275 on the LME
Cochilco's 21 October report put LME cash copper at $14,441 a tonne and showed exchange stocks of 718,381 tonnes on COMEX, 245,275 on the LME and 73,962 in Shanghai.
Where stocks sit is Cochilco's explanation for why a forecast surplus has not lowered prices.
1 report · one development
Reports sharing an origin are coverage, not independent confirmation.
Oct 16, 2026
Copper dips 0.64% on the week; annual average 40% above 2025
Cochilco reported copper closing the week at $6.6 a pound, down 0.64%, with the annual average $6.12, 40.38% above the same date in 2025, and attributed the dip to the Escondida labour agreement, US inflation pressure and investor selling.
Shows copper's strength persisting through a week of weaker risk sentiment.
1 report · one development
Reports sharing an origin are coverage, not independent confirmation.
Oct 2, 2026
World Bank: energy index up 25.7% in September, non-energy up 1.3%
The World Bank's October Pink Sheet showed the energy index up 25.7% in September and the non-energy index up 1.3%, with metals up 0.4% and precious metals down 1.9%.
The month's momentum was energy alone, which is the concentration reading of this narrative.
2 reports · one development
Reports sharing an origin are coverage, not independent confirmation.
Aug 11, 2026
Cochilco raises its 2026 copper price forecast to $5.95 a pound
Cochilco raised its 2026 average copper price forecast to $5.95 a pound, kept 2027 at $5.10, and projected a refined surplus of 225,000 tonnes in 2026, small because inventories concentrated in the US restrict availability in Asia.
Sets the copper baseline: forecast surpluses alongside record-level prices.
1 report · one development
Reports sharing an origin are coverage, not independent confirmation.
Evidence
Sources: Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) ×9 · World Bank ×6 · U.S. Energy Information Administration
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
The energy price index surged by 25.7% in September, led by crude oil (+21.2%) and natural gas (+15.3%). The non-energy index edged up 1.3%, with food prices rising 3.8% and fertilizers increasing by 0.4%. […] Metals were broadly stable, increasing 0.4%, while precious metals eased 1.9%.
Scope and limits: Month-on-month changes for September 2026. The page is replaced at each monthly update (next: 3 November); the same data are in the October 2026 Pink Sheet PDF.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
Overall commodity prices are forecast to rise 16% in 2026, driven by soaring energy and fertilizer prices and record-high prices for several key metals.
Scope and limits: The April 2026 Commodity Markets Outlook as summarised on the World Bank's page; a forecast made before later price moves, due to be updated in the October 2026 edition.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
Energy 107.0 101.5 90.0 89.1 83.7 105.3 130.1 125.4 108.8 118.5 148.9 Non Energy 110.2 112.5 115.4 114.0 116.1 121.0 127.1 128.4 125.9 128.8 130.5 Agriculture 110.9 115.0 115.7 113.2 112.1 111.3 114.6 119.4 117.5 119.4 121.3
Scope and limits: Columns: annual averages 2023, 2024, 2025; quarterly averages Q3 2025, Q4 2025, Q1 2026, Q2 2026, Q3 2026; monthly averages July, August, September 2026. Nominal US dollar indices, 2010=100. Index changes measure price levels, not volumes or demand.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
Grains 133.0 112.9 101.3 95.9 99.0 103.9 110.1 119.8 114.5 119.4 125.4 […] Fertilizers 153.5 117.6 138.7 153.4 137.6 154.7 188.2 147.6 149.3 146.4 147.0
Scope and limits: Columns: annual averages 2023, 2024, 2025; quarterly averages Q3 2025, Q4 2025, Q1 2026, Q2 2026, Q3 2026; monthly averages July, August, September 2026. Sub-indices, 2010=100. They do not show whether the rise reflects energy costs or crop conditions.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
Metals and Minerals 104.0 106.7 112.2 111.1 121.8 137.1 145.7 144.7 140.5 146.2 147.5 Base Metals e/ 109.0 114.1 122.3 121.0 133.6 152.5 162.8 162.8 157.5 164.8 166.2 Precious Metals 147.3 180.2 258.6 259.7 317.9 393.1 359.6 333.7 317.2 345.2 338.6
Scope and limits: Columns: annual averages 2023, 2024, 2025; quarterly averages Q3 2025, Q4 2025, Q1 2026, Q2 2026, Q3 2026; monthly averages July, August, September 2026. Nominal US dollar indices, 2010=100; index composition is defined in the Pink Sheet's notes. Price levels only, not volumes or demand.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
World Bank · Oct 2, 2026
Copper $/mt b/ 8,490 9,142 9,947 9,808 11,112 12,831 13,349 14,114 13,543 14,326 14,474 Iron ore $/dmt b/ 120.6 109.4 100.2 100.1 103.5 102.9 105.2 97.4 98.2 96.3 97.7
Scope and limits: Columns: annual averages 2023, 2024, 2025; quarterly averages Q3 2025, Q4 2025, Q1 2026, Q2 2026, Q3 2026; monthly averages July, August, September 2026. Copper is LME grade A cash in US dollars per tonne; iron ore is 62% Fe fines c.f.r. China in US dollars per dry tonne. Averages, not point prices.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Oct 21, 2026
Contado 14.441,00 -0,68 […] Año a la fecha 13.516,45 40,31
Scope and limits: LME grade A copper in US dollars per tonne (Spanish number format): cash price on 21 October 2026 with its daily % change, and the year-to-date average with its % change on the same date in 2025. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Oct 21, 2026
20-oct-2026 233.800 21-oct-2026 245.275 11.475 […] 19-oct-2026 718.199 20-oct-2026 718.381 181 […] 9-oct-2026 58.744 16-oct-2026 73.962 15.218
Scope and limits: Copper stocks in tonnes, with the change: LME (opening, 20–21 October), COMEX (close, 19–20 October) and Shanghai Futures Exchange (close, 9–16 October). Exchange stocks only; off-exchange and bonded stocks are not covered.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Oct 16, 2026
El precio del cobre cerró hoy en US$ 6,6 la libra, con una baja de 0,64% respecto al cierre de la semana anterior. Con este resultado, el promedio anual alcanzó US$ 6,12 por libra, lo que representa un aumento de 40,38% respecto de la misma fecha de 2025.
Scope and limits: Cochilco's weekly copper report for 12–16 October 2026 (the page's URL slug refers to an earlier week, but its content is this one). LME price in US dollars per pound, rounded. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Oct 16, 2026
El acuerdo laboral en Escondida, las presiones inflacionarias estadounidenses y las ventas de inversionistas explicaron la corrección.
Scope and limits: Cochilco's attribution of one week's price dip; it is not a quantified analysis. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Aug 11, 2026
En cuanto al balance del mercado, Cochilco proyecta para 2026 un superávit de cobre refinado de 225 mil toneladas, equivalente a solo 0,8% de la demanda mundial.
Scope and limits: An August 2026 forecast (Q2 copper market trends report); it predates September's price moves. Other forecasters' balances differ by method. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Aug 11, 2026
La entidad precisó que esta cifra no supone un escenario de sobreabastecimiento, ya que la concentración de inventarios en Estados Unidos restringe la disponibilidad del metal en Asia.
Scope and limits: Cochilco's explanation; it does not quantify the effect or name the cause of the US stock build. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Aug 11, 2026
Para 2027, en tanto, el organismo prevé que el superávit de cobre refinado disminuirá a 179 mil toneladas, cifra equivalente a 0,6% del consumo mundial.
Scope and limits: A forecast made in August 2026. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Aug 11, 2026
la lenta recuperación de la mina Grasberg, en Indonesia; las dificultades del yacimiento Kamoa-Kakula, en la República Democrática del Congo; y los menores volúmenes de producción de Codelco, Escondida y Spence mantendrían restringida la disponibilidad de concentrados durante este año.
Scope and limits: Names the constraints Cochilco expects to limit concentrate supply in 2026; no volumes per mine in this passage. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Comisión Chilena del Cobre (Cochilco) · Aug 11, 2026
Cochilco eleva a US$ 5,95 la libra su proyección para el precio promedio del cobre en 2026 Para 2027, mantuvo su estimación en US$ 5,10 la libra.
Scope and limits: Headline and standfirst of Cochilco's August 2026 release: average-price forecasts in US dollars per pound, not price targets. Cochilco's text is in Spanish; Finquill's translation is in the claims.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
U.S. Energy Information Administration · Oct 6, 2026
Brent crude oil (dollars per barrel) 81 69 96 84
Scope and limits: EIA's annual Brent spot averages: 2024 and 2025 actual, 2026 and 2027 forecast, from the October 2026 STEO overview table. Analysis of the oil leg is in the Hormuz oil shock narrative.
Retrieved Oct 21, 2026.
Coverage scope: Global commodity prices by sector. The breadth gauge is the World Bank's monthly Pink Sheet indices (energy, non-energy, agriculture, grains, fertilizers, metals and minerals, base metals, precious metals). Copper is covered directly: LME, COMEX and Shanghai prices and exchange stocks, and supply-and-demand forecasts, via Cochilco (Chile's state copper commission). Oil is covered in the Hormuz oil shock narrative and gold in Gold after the fall; this narrative links to them rather than repeating them. Out of scope: individual agricultural markets below index level, lithium and rare earths, equities.
Update history
- Update 1 · Oct 27, 2026 · this page
Free account. See what changed since your last visit, and the dates to watch on your calendar. Following never means agreeing.
Analytics, not investment advice. How Finquill tracks narratives · Report an issue